🐕‍🦺 ACANA Singles Limited Ingredient Dry Dog Food

 ACANA Singles Limited Ingredient Dry Dog Food (Duck & Pear Recipe) and how it compares to Whole Earth Farms Grain-Free Salmon & Whitefish:

---

ACANA Singles Duck & Pear (4.5 lb) Overview

Key Features:

• Single Animal Protein: Duck (fresh & dried) as the sole protein source—ideal for dogs with food sensitivities.

• Limited Ingredients: Only 8 key components (duck, duck meal, whole peas, whole lentils, duck fat, pear, pumpkin, sunflower oil).

• Grain-Free: No corn, wheat, soy, or artificial additives.

• Nutrient Profile:

• Crude Protein: 27% min

• Crude Fat: 15% min

• Crude Fiber: 5% max

• Calories: ~400 kcal/cup

Pros:
✅ Hypoallergenic: Great for dogs with protein allergies (single-source duck).
✅ Low-Carb: Uses lentils/peas instead of potatoes.
✅ WholePrey Ingredients: Includes organs (liver, heart) for natural nutrients.

Cons:
⚠️ Expensive: ~$25\text{–}$30 for a 4.5-lb bag (vs. $45\text{–}$60 for 25 lbs of Whole Earth Farms).
⚠️ Not for Picky Eaters: Some dogs dislike duck’s gamey flavor.

---

Comparison: ACANA Singles Duck & Pear vs. Whole Earth Farms Salmon & Whitefish

Feature	ACANA Singles Duck & Pear	Whole Earth Farms Salmon & Whitefish
Protein Source	Duck only (single-protein)	Salmon + Whitefish (dual-protein)
Main Carbs	Peas, lentils	Peas, potatoes
Protein %	27%	26%
Fat %	15%	14%
Grain-Free?	Yes	Yes
Added Probiotics?	No	No
Price per Pound	~$5.50\text{–}$6.60/lb	~$1.80\text{–}$2.40/lb
Best For	Dogs with severe allergies, limited-ingredient needs	Budget-friendly grain-free, general sensitivity

---

Which to Choose?

• Pick ACANA Singles If:

  • Your dog has known protein allergies (e.g., reacts to chicken, beef, or fish).

  • You need a minimalist recipe for elimination diets.

  • Budget isn’t a concern (small bags for trial feeding).

• Pick Whole Earth Farms If:

  • You need a cost-effective grain-free option for general sensitivities.

  • Your dog tolerates fish-based proteins well.

  • You prefer larger bags (25 lb) for big dogs or multi-dog households.

---

Alternatives to Consider:

1. For Limited-Ingredient Diets:

   • Natural Balance L.I.D. Duck & Potato (similar to ACANA but with potatoes).

   • Canidae Pure Duck Recipe (adds probiotics).

2. For Budget Grain-Free:

• Taste of the Wild Prairie (bison-based, mid-range price).

• Nutro Wholesome Essentials Salmon & Lentils.